top of page

The Ultimate Guide to the Best Places to Live in Indiana: Top 10 Rankings


Indianapolis skyline

In this article we unveil the top 10 places to live in the captivating state of Indiana. From bustling cities brimming with energy to picturesque small towns emanating peace and serenity, Indiana offers a diverse range of communities that cater to every lifestyle and preference. Get ready to discover the hidden gems and thriving hubs that make Indiana a truly enchanting place to call home.


#1. Carmel


Our first stop takes us to the remarkable city of Carmel, a place that captured national attention back in 2015 when Money magazine hailed it as the finest small city to reside in within the entire United States. And now, Carmel has once again reclaimed the spotlight by securing the coveted title of the best place to live in Indiana, as determined by niche.com. Nestled in Hamilton County, this city is a mere stone's throw away, just under 16 miles, from the bustling capital of Indiana, Indianapolis.


Beyond its appealing attributes as a place to live, Carmel offers a wide array of activities and attractions. The city is known for its vibrant arts and culture scene, with numerous galleries, theaters, and live performance venues showcasing the talent of local artists. Music enthusiasts can enjoy concerts and festivals held throughout the year, while art lovers can explore the diverse exhibitions and workshops available.


Carmel is also a haven for outdoor enthusiasts, with an extensive network of parks and recreational areas. Residents can explore the miles of picturesque trails for hiking, biking, or leisurely walks, immersing themselves in the natural beauty of the region. The city's parks often host community events and gatherings, fostering a strong sense of togetherness among residents.


Population: 98,137

Median home sold price: $489,187

Median monthly rental price: $1,348


#2. Meridian Hills


Prepare to be captivated by the charm of Meridian Hills, an exquisite suburb that has rightfully earned its place among the best places to call home in Indiana. Combining luxury, tranquility, and unbeatable convenience, Meridian Hills caters to individuals and families seeking an exceptional lifestyle. The striking homes in this exclusive enclave are meticulously maintained, showcasing architectural marvels nestled amidst lush landscapes. As you stroll along the tree-lined streets and admire the spacious lots, a serene and picturesque atmosphere envelops you.


Education takes center stage in Meridian Hills, with easy access to some of the finest schools in the area, ensuring a first-rate learning experience for the young minds that reside here. The neighborhood's proximity to downtown Indianapolis offers the best of both worlds, allowing residents to relish the serenity of suburban life while remaining just a short drive away from the vibrant urban center.

Moreover, the strong sense of community in Meridian Hills fosters an environment of warmth and belonging, with residents actively participating in neighborhood events and activities. This harmonious blend of upscale living, convenience, and a welcoming community solidifies Meridian Hills' reputation as one of the premier places to lay down roots in Indiana.


Population: 1,736

Median home sold price: $820,000

Median monthly rental price: $1,176


#3. Westfield


Next on our journey, we arrive in Westfield, a community that stands tall among Indiana's top-tier locations to call home. This Indianapolis suburb boasts an array of outstanding qualities that make it an attractive destination for individuals and families alike. At the forefront is the exceptional quality of education, with both public and private schools in Westfield consistently ranking among the highest-achieving institutions in the state. Residents also enjoy the advantage of shorter commutes, thanks to the proximity to the metropolis of Indianapolis.


When it comes to Westfield, there's one standout feature that sets it apart: the renowned Grand Park. This sprawling youth sports campus is a true gem, boasting an impressive collection of outdoor fields and a state-of-the-art indoor facility for basketball and volleyball. With its vast expanse and top-notch amenities, Grand Park has become a hub for hosting numerous large-scale sporting events and tournaments, attracting athletes and spectators from near and far.


With its unbeatable sports facilities and outstanding education system, Westfield emerges as an ideal place for families seeking a well-rounded and enriching lifestyle.


Population: 45,695

Median home sold price: $418,533

Median monthly rental price: $1,234


#4. Georgetown


Nestled in the scenic countryside of southern Indiana, the charming town of Georgetown emerges as an excellent choice for those seeking the perfect balance between small-town charm and modern conveniences. With its peaceful and tight-knit community atmosphere, Georgetown invites residents to embrace a tranquil lifestyle surrounded by natural beauty. One of the town's standout features is its affordable cost of housing, making it an appealing option for families and individuals seeking both comfort and budget-friendly living.


Georgetown provides an array of amenities, including parks, recreational facilities, and local businesses, ensuring that residents have convenient access to everyday necessities. Furthermore, the top-rated schools in Georgetown deliver outstanding educational opportunities, ensuring that children receive a stellar education in a nurturing environment.


The town's proximity to the bustling city of Louisville, Kentucky, offers residents the added advantage of easy access to a broader range of employment opportunities, entertainment options, and cultural events. Embracing a strong sense of community, Georgetown fosters a spirit of belonging and neighborly support. With its affordable housing, quality schools, and proximity to urban amenities, Georgetown stands tall as an excellent choice for a comfortable and fulfilling lifestyle in Indiana.


Population: 3,703

Median home sold price: $320,000

Median monthly rental price: $778


#5. Zionsville


Welcome to the vibrant community of Zionsville, nestled in picturesque Boone County, where over 25,000 residents have found their haven for an exceptional living experience. Zionsville takes great pride in its education system, boasting some of the finest public schools in the entire country. Students in Zionsville benefit from a top-notch education, thanks to the dedicated teachers and innovative programs that foster a love for learning and academic excellence.


Safety and security are paramount in Zionsville, as the city proudly holds the title of one of the safest cities in Indiana. Residents can enjoy peace of mind knowing that their community prioritizes their well-being and takes proactive measures to maintain a safe environment for all.


Beyond its exceptional schools and commitment to safety, Zionsville offers a charming small-town atmosphere with a thriving downtown area. The town center is adorned with historic buildings, boutiques, and locally owned shops, creating a delightful setting for leisurely strolls and exploring unique treasures. Additionally, Zionsville hosts various community events and festivals throughout the year, providing opportunities for neighbors to come together and celebrate their shared sense of community.


Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the abundance of parks and green spaces that grace Zionsville. The town is home to scenic trails, perfect for hiking, biking, and enjoying the beauty of the great outdoors. Residents can relish the serenity of these natural spaces, allowing for moments of tranquility and relaxation.


With its exceptional schools, commitment to safety, and a vibrant downtown area, Zionsville offers its residents a well-rounded living experience. Whether you're seeking quality education, a tight-knit community, or access to outdoor recreational opportunities, Zionsville is the perfect place to call home.


Population: 30,258

Median home sold price: $625,000

Median monthly rental price: $1,451



#6. Darmstadt


Prepare to be enchanted by the captivating blend of rural charm and modern amenities that define Darmstadt, Indiana. Located just outside of Evansville, this town beckons with its tranquil atmosphere and breathtaking natural scenery. A true gem, Darmstadt thrives on its strong sense of community, where residents from diverse walks of life come together for regular celebrations and community projects, fostering a vibrant tapestry of togetherness.


For those seeking an active and healthy lifestyle, Darmstadt offers a plethora of parks, playgrounds, and fishing areas, allowing residents to revel in the beauty of their surroundings. The city's stellar reputation extends to its schools, ensuring that every student receives a top-notch education. Proximity to Evansville also grants convenient access to a variety of businesses, retail centers, culinary establishments, and cultural attractions, offering the best of both rural and urban experiences. With its tranquil atmosphere, strong community spirit, and proximity to both rural and urban attractions, Darmstadt, Indiana, emerges as an exceptional place to call home.


Population: 1,284

Median home sold price: $884,500

Median monthly rental price: $933


#7. Dyer


Welcome to the charming town of Dyer, where residents find solace in a safe haven with crime rates significantly lower than the state average. This aspect alone makes Dyer an ideal choice for families seeking peace of mind and a secure environment for their loved ones. However, the allure of Dyer extends far beyond safety, as the town is renowned for providing a high quality of life.


Dyer takes great pride in its exceptional schools, ensuring that children receive an education of the highest caliber. The town's commitment to education is evident in its renowned school system, which prepares students for a bright and successful future. Families are drawn to Dyer from far and wide for its access to some of the best schools in the country, recognizing the immense value of a top-notch education for their children.


Living in Dyer means embracing a high standard of living, with a focus on quality and comfort. The town offers a range of amenities and services that cater to residents' needs, from well-maintained parks and recreational facilities to convenient shopping and dining options. The strong sense of community in Dyer fosters a supportive and welcoming environment, where neighbors come together to create lasting connections and meaningful relationships.


With its emphasis on safety, exceptional schools, strong sense of community, and a focus on quality of life, Dyer promises a rewarding and prosperous lifestyle for its residents. Embrace the inviting charm of this lovely town south of Munster and discover why Dyer is a place where families thrive and dreams flourish.


Population: 16,422

Median home sold price: $692,445

Median monthly rental price: $1,182


#8. Santa Claus


Prepare to embark on a magical journey as we arrive in Santa Claus, Indiana, a truly enchanting place to live. As the name suggests, this delightful town exudes the spirit of Christmas all year round, creating an atmosphere of joy and wonder. Living in Santa Claus is an experience like no other, as residents immerse themselves in the holiday spirit that permeates every corner of the town. From festive events to activities that honor the magic of Christmas, residents of Santa Claus find themselves in a perpetual celebration of the holiday season.


One of the standout features of Santa Claus is its friendly and close-knit community. The residents here embrace the holiday spirit and actively participate in events and activities that foster a sense of togetherness. A true gem of Santa Claus is the world-renowned Holiday World & Splashin' Safari, a magnificent theme park that attracts visitors from all over the globe. Residents of Santa Claus have the incredible opportunity to enjoy the thrilling rides and water attractions of this spectacular park right in their own backyard.


Safety and security are paramount in Santa Claus, as the town boasts a low crime rate, allowing residents to enjoy a strong sense of safety and peace. Moreover, Santa Claus takes great pride in its exceptional schools, ensuring that children receive a top-notch education in a nurturing environment. With beautiful parks, picturesque neighborhoods, and an abundance of recreational opportunities, Santa Claus offers its residents a high quality of life.


Living in Santa Claus is like waking up every day in a Christmas dream, making it the ultimate destination for those seeking the magic and joy of Christmas all year round.


Population: 2,718

Median home sold price: $232,500

Median monthly rental price: $1,105


#9. Westville


Nestled in the heart of Indiana, the delightful town of Westville offers its residents a truly pleasant living experience. Situated near the bustling city of Indianapolis, this charming small town provides an array of amenities that make it a joy to call home. Whether you're in the mood for shopping, dining, or immersing yourself in nature, Westville has something for everyone.


The town boasts numerous shopping centers, restaurants, and parks, ensuring there's always something to do and explore. For those with an affinity for music and art, Westville's vibrant music and art scene provide endless opportunities to indulge in cultural experiences. The mild and comfortable weather that graces Westville throughout most of the year invites residents to relax and enjoy the great outdoors.


One of the true highlights of Westville is its friendly and welcoming community. The people of Westville exude warmth and hospitality, making it effortless for newcomers to adjust and find their place within the town. All in all, Westville is an excellent place to call home, offering the perfect blend of small-town charm and convenient access to nearby urban amenities.


Population: 6,062

Median home sold price: $474,217

Median monthly rental price: $723


#10. Greendale


Last but certainly not least, we arrive in the wonderful town of Greendale, Indiana, where the present moment is an exciting time to call this place home. Greendale strikes a perfect balance between small-town serenity and close proximity to the vibrant city of Indianapolis. This unique blend allows residents to savor the tranquility of a small town while still having easy access to the plethora of services and opportunities that a bustling city offers.


Greendale is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts, boasting an abundance of parks and recreational activities. Whether you enjoy hiking, biking, or simply taking leisurely strolls, Greendale's parks and nearby nature areas provide the perfect backdrop for outdoor adventures. The town's focus on family-friendly amenities and activities makes it an ideal choice for those with children, as there are numerous parks and fun attractions nearby.


Beyond its recreational offerings, Greendale is renowned for its strong sense of community and local pride. Many residents have deep roots in the town, with families having lived there for generations. This deep-rooted sense of community fosters a welcoming environment where neighbors look out for one another and actively engage in local events and initiatives.


Greendale offers a delightful escape from the bustling city noise while still providing easy access to the services and conveniences of Indianapolis. With its friendly community, ample outdoor spaces, and a myriad of activities, Greendale truly has something for everyone. So, if you're looking for a place to settle down that offers the best of both worlds, Greendale is undoubtedly an excellent choice.


Population: 4,009

Median home sold price: $224,950

Median monthly rental price: $535


Conclusion


From the bustling urban allure of Carmel and Meridian Hills to the captivating small-town charm of Georgetown and Darmstadt, Indiana presents an impressive array of captivating destinations that cater to a wide range of preferences. Whether one's heart yearns for the vibrant energy of a thriving city or the tranquility of a serene suburban haven, Indiana stands ready to deliver. We invite you to share your thoughts in the comments section below, revealing which of these remarkable locales resonates with you the most. As we bring this extraordinary journey to a close, we extend our heartfelt gratitude for your presence and encourage you to remain engaged with our future content.


Here are 10 things to know and do in Indiana:

  • Explore the Stunning Architecture of Indianapolis: Visit the Indiana State Capitol, the Soldiers and Sailors Monument, and the Indianapolis Museum of Art.

  • Experience the Thrills of the Indy 500: Attend the iconic Indianapolis 500 at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.

  • Discover the Charm of Brown County: Immerse yourself in the natural beauty and artistic culture of Brown County.

  • Dive into History at the Indiana State Museum: Learn about Indiana's rich history and heritage at the Indiana State Museum.

  • Visit the Historic French Lick Resort: Indulge in luxury and history at the French Lick Resort, known for its grandeur and world-class amenities.

  • Explore the Dunes at Indiana Dunes National Park: Enjoy the scenic beauty of Lake Michigan and hike the picturesque sand dunes at Indiana Dunes National Park.

  • Sample Delicious Treats at the Indianapolis City Market: Experience a wide array of culinary delights and local specialties at the historic Indianapolis City Market.

  • Visit the Amish Country in Shipshewana: Discover the traditional lifestyle of the Amish community in Shipshewana, known for its quaint shops and markets.

  • Attend a Festival in Bloomington: Immerse yourself in the vibrant cultural scene of Bloomington by attending one of its many festivals, such as the Lotus World Music & Arts Festival.

  • Explore the Quaint Town of Madison: Stroll through the charming streets of Madison, known for its well-preserved historic architecture and scenic river views.

Comments


bottom of page